Re: [TML] HIWG CD Notes Kelly St. Clair 12 Sep 2020 08:29 UTC

On 9/11/2020 8:48 PM, Phil Pugliese - philpugliese at yahoo.com (via tml
list) wrote:
> Of course, but I'm speaking to the period AFTER the ZS 'surrendered'.
>
> As the 2I spread the info concerning a 'New Way' it would only be
> natural that many folks, non-solomani folks, would want to jump on the
> winner's bandwagon.
>
> That's why I can't see that there's very much of, except in a few cases,
> a star-spanning traditional vilani social structure still around by 1100 3I.
>
> It's just too inefficient to compete & has been for the thousands of
> years since they contacted the terrans.

A case could be made (and probably would be, by Vilani traditionalists -
but I repeat myself) that "the old system was working /just fine/, as it
had for thousands of years ... but no, you had to tinker, to experiment,
to try the 'New Way.'  And it /failed/, and that's how we got the Long
Night.  And that's why we don't change what /works/.  If we'd just stuck
with the old ways, none of this would have happened."

Which is bullshit, of course - the ZS was already starting to crack and
fail under its own weight and age before the Terrans ever showed up -
but to a certain sort, it makes a convenient excuse / scapegoat, a
"proof" of why "reckless" changes are always bad and good old Vilani
conservatism is the truth and the light.

--
---------------
Kelly St. Clair
xxxxxx@efn.org