On 7/21/2015 8:50 PM, Richard Aiken wrote:
Then we're talking about the same missions. The approach would be as stealthy as possible. Torpedoes were used when possible, but only usually worked against the biggest boats; the medium to small ones didn't have deep enough drafts. Shooting the targets was the very definitely second choice, since these "targets" could send back quite a heavy volume of return fire.

He hated torpedo runs because they were usually against something that was large enough to be a stable gun platform that mounted something that would be a one shot kill if it hit...and they had to go in a straight line to line up for the launch.

  
...or, landing shore parties to collect intelligence and then backing off for a couple hours before moving in to recover the shore parties.

And hopefully no gunplay at all would be involved there.

Hopefully.  But they did get some rather interesting training according to my dad and IIRC his quartermaster.

My father had a lot of stories about his years commanding a PT boat in the South Pacific and one thing he impressed on me was that each time they went out it was rarely boring or a "sit and drift" mission.

90% of war is boring. Even the tension of waiting for the enemy to appear gets boring. There's only so long the body can stay tense.
 
  Torpedoes became so rarely used that they removed two of the four for better performance and replaced them with more machine guns.

The crews were always looking up up-gun their boats. In that way they were actually quite a bit like PCs. I recall reading of one boat which replaced it's fantail smoke generator with an ex-Army 75mm pack howitzer (the writer of the account was deliberately vague as to how the crew acquired the weapon . . .). IIRC they were never able to confirm having scored any hits using it [from the stern of a wildly bouncing/corkscrewing PT boat]. But firing it in action in the vague direction of the incoming fire apparently helped crew morale considerably.


LOL!  True.  By the end of the war my dad's boat had been modified to lose the two aft torpedoes, the forward tubes had been swapped for roll off cradles, and the weapons (from bow to stern) were a 37mm, two single 20mm, a pair of 8 shot rocket launchers, M-1919 LMGs on each side of the navigation bridge, a twin .50cal, a 20mm on the deckhouse, and a 40mm Bofors in the stern.  The two torpedo tubes that were removed were usually replaced with a pair of roll off depth charges (used mostly for fishing or sending a destructive monkey to the hereafter).  The crew had a variety of arms ranging from SMGs to BARs; his rule was if you had to take your hands off the trigger and stock to do anything other than reload it, it wasn't allowed on the boat. 

Looking back, I truly believe that he was a PC during the war.

--
Kurt Feltenberger
kurt@thepaw.org/kfeltenberger@yahoo.com
“Before today, I was scared to live, after today, I'm scared I'm not living enough." - Me