Joseph,
The mission of any system is elaborated by what it does, not by what its called.
For example if I call the school bus a Transatlantic Ghormophonic Extravoyager, its system function would remain to collect children from their homes and to deliver them to school.

What was the function of the BMP-1?
It was armed with a gun firing an anti-tank rocket, a guided anti-tank missile, and had a team of anti-tank rocket-propelled grenadiers as passengers. It also had a team of riflemen to provide support for the grenadiers and the anti-tank missile operator when dismounted. Given that most passengers of the BMP-1 and most of its weapons were to be used in either anti-tank role or to support anti-tank combat tasks, the BMP-1 was an anti-tank vehicle.

The BMP-1 replaced the BTR-50, which was also an anti-tank vehicle. It was unusually large, and seated 20 'infantrymen'...on Moscow parades. In the field it seated ten artillery crew, towed a 100mm anti-tank gun and the rest of the cargo space was occupied by ammunition.

25mm APFSDS-DU rounds could under certain circumstances penetrate some of the T-55 and T-72 armour.
The Bradley vehicle needs to find itself in a favourable orientation to the target first.
However, the M919 ammunition was approved for production in 1996, three years after the Cold War ended.
The chances that a small (~100g) penetrator rod of causing serious enough damage to destroy an MBT is small, but not to be discounted of course.

Greg

On 19 June 2015 at 03:35, Joseph Paul <josephnjody@sbcglobal.net> wrote:
"The Bradley was designed to 'outdo' the BMP-1, but its designers didn't realise what the BMP-1 design mission requirements were."

The mission of the BMP-1 was to provide mobility for infantry so they could keep pace with the armored elements and to provide supporting direct fire and anti-armor capability to those infantry.

The mission of the Bradely is to provide mobility for infantry so they can keep pace with the armor and to provide supporting direct fire and anti-armor capability to those infantry.

I am not seeing a failure here particularly in light of the successes in actually killing T-55 and T-72 tanks with 25mm rounds.

So just what do you think the BMP-1's mission was?


Joseph Paul
By My Hand Designs LLC
4221 N Park Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46205
317-931-0561


-----
The Traveller Mailing List
Archives at http://archives.simplelists.com/tml
Report problems to listmom@travellercentral.com
To unsubscribe from this list please goto http://www.simplelists.com/confirm.php?u=JydxSB9tZc6TS63HiAHJcg6SAwighNGJ