Re: ANPA egroup: Fwd: Doctors everywhere but no hospitals for them (TRUST) cvclinic4oao@aol.com 13 Mar 2016 11:17 CDT

Complex situation with plenty of blames to go around! For example, I had no idea about how much strikes crippled healthcare delivery in the public sector, or how little emphasis is placed on technical training for operating complex equipment purchased by politicians and their business counterparts  for use in many of the public hospitals, and so on, till I visited some hospitals last year to learn about the healthcare environment in Nigeria.

Nkem, please ask the MDCN what they are doing to effectively help the diaspora physicians who are trying to make a difference in Nigeria...In July and November 2015 I made multiple trips to the MDCN in Abuja for new license (registration), was assured that everything was complete and to expect my approved registration in 2weeks. About 8weeks later I got a text message from "management" advising me that my registration is available for pick up at Enugu zonal office on presentation of the original copy of my degree certificate...I have tried but have not been able to talk directly to someone about any aspect of this message, even the Registrar himself is not returning my messages or answering phone calls. I can give you specifics privately. My plans are delayed for now about venturing into Nigeria...I saw personally a pervasive lack of interest, concern, respect for our fellow professionals in my visits to the MDCN and some of the Teaching hospitals that I visited. I point it out here to add to your discussion points when you visit MDCN next week. Others can add from their experiences as well. The rhetoric we hear from our esteemed colleagues from Nigeria when they come (at our expense usually) to speak at ANPA meetings in the US does not match the apathy that many of us experience on the ground in their turf in Nigeria...a huge promise to delivery gap exists...

Osita A. Onyekwere, MD, MBA, FACC, FSCAI
Cardiac and Vascular Consultants, LLC

Sent from my iPhone

> On Mar 13, 2016, at 10:37 AM, Nkem Chukwumerije <nkem67@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> This truly is troubling and we will add this to our discussion points with MDCN next week in Abuja.
>
> Thanks for sharing
>
> Grace and Peace
> Nkem Chukwumerije
>
>> On Mar 13, 2016, at 6:06 AM, Michael Etomi (via anpa list) <nobody@simplelists.com> wrote:
>>
>> This email was sent from aol.com which does not allow forwarding of emails via email lists. Therefore the sender's email address (metoks@aol.com) has been replaced with a dummy one. The original message follows:
>>
>> Very disturbing
>>
>> Sent from my iPhone: Michael Etomi,MD,MPH,FASN
>>>
>>> Doctors everywhere but no hospitals for them
>>>
>>> By Nuruddeen M. Abdallah, Judd Leonard, Ojoma Akor (Abuja), Nahimah Ajikanle-Nuruddeen (Lagos), Dele Og | Publish Date: Mar 13 2016 5:00AM
>>> Samson Ajayi, a medical graduate of the University of Ilorin, has been going from one teaching hospital to another for some months, looking for a place to do his one-year mandatory housemanship. The only reason the hospitals have not taken him is quota barrier.
>>> Also, Dr Tajudeen Ayedun, who graduated from the Obafemi Awolowo University (OAU), said he had already wasted one academic session running from one hospital to another in search of a slot for his housemanship. Another medical doctor in Kano, Zuwairiyya Sullayman, said she had applied to virtually all the general hospitals in Abuja, the State House Clinic, and some general hospitals in Kaduna State before she finally got a slot in the Aminu Kano Teaching Hospital (AKTH).
>>>
>>> These are some of the experiences of young medical doctors in Nigeria who are struggling to secure spaces for their one-year post graduation housemanship.
>>>
>>> The predicament of teaching hospitals
>>> Findings across the country show that accredited hospitals and health centres are inundated with thousands of applications for the internship annually, but they have limited capacities to absorb the doctors.
>>> Investigations by Daily Trust on Sunday revealed that inadequate funding, dearth of infrastructure, poor regulation of the number of medical students, and insecurity, are some of the factors responsible for the training deficiency.
>>> Dr Haruna Yusuph, head of Clinical Immunology and Infectious Diseases, University of Maiduguri, said consultant-house officers ratio, personnel cost and staggered graduation were the three main factors that determined the number of house officers allocated to health facilities.
>>> The chief medical director of the Usman Danfodiyo Teaching Hospital, Dr Ahmed Yakubu, blamed the deficiency on incessant strikes by lecturers and medical workers, over-admission by universities, inadequate funds, and the capacity to accommodate all the applicants.
>>> He said, “We have very limited spaces. The finances are equally limited. Some teaching hospitals could not pay the salaries of their staff. Some paid only 30 to 50 per cent of their staff salaries.
>>> “Incessant strikes by the Academic Staff Union of Universities (ASUU) usually cripple and distort academic calendars of tertiary institutions. In most cases, such strikes force these universities to graduate two sets of medical doctors and pharmacists at the same time. Because of the lack of capacity and adequate funds to pay, it is impossible for teaching hospitals to accommodate all of them. The production is more than the consumption,” he said.
>>> The secretary of the Nigerian Medical Association (NMA) in the Jos University Teaching Hospital (JUTH), Dr Mershak Daniel, said, “It is worrisome that we have stopped growing as a nation in the health sector while the number of doctors seeking housemanship keeps increasing yearly. Before, health facilities accepted as many as the universities graduated for the mandatory housemanship. Today, the situation is different because of lack of spaces for service.”
>>> Dr Daniel said the Medical and Dental Council of Nigeria (MDCN) could approve only limited spaces at a time, even when there is an immense pressure on the facilities for service.
>>> The secretary of the Association of Resident Doctors (ARD) in JUTH, Dr Paul Agbo, said the bad situation had not only put pressure on the facility, “the few doctors accepted are overworked.”
>>> But despite inadequate funding, managements of some of these teaching health facilities are to blame, a doctor in Zaria who declined being named for fear of victimisation said.
>>> “The major problem is that when you go to a teaching hospital and the unit where housemanship is done, you will find out that they have slots for 120 to 180 students, but they may employ only 80 people while the money meant for 180 people goes to the hospital management.
>>> “The hospital is supposed to admit 120 house officers on a yearly basis, but unfortunately, only 60 people were admitted in the last interview, out of which less than 40 resumed,” he said.
>>> The chief medical director of the University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital, Enugu, Dr Chris Amah, told Daily Trust on Sunday that unemployment was making doctors reluctant to leave after the completion of their internship.
>>> “One thing we have also realised is that because of unemployment, those who have been admitted for internship are now reluctant to leave. Of course, the interns are paid. If you are a medical doctor on housemanship, you are paid like a doctor; same applies to pharmacists.
>>> “Some of them do not want to finish and leave. So they recycle themselves. They will finish internship here and still go to repeat it in a different hospital. They are sure of their pay if they remain in the hospital. This is what we have discovered and it has worsened the situation,” he said.
>>> He further said that insurgency in some parts of the country was fuelling the exodus of doctors to the southern part of the country. “Because of security challenge right now, you can hardly get a house officer who wants to go to the University of Maiduguri Teaching Hospital,” he said.
>>> He suggested that government should expand the scope of the institutions in terms of adequate funding while the regulatory bodies should allow them to absorb more interns.
>>> The chief medical director of the Lagos State University Teaching Hospital (LASUTH), Prof. Wale Oke, said the problem could be addressed by accrediting private hospitals for the training. He said there were many private hospitals in the country with facilities to train house officers, but they need government accreditation.
>>> He added, “There are many people waiting for housemanship and not finding spaces because some people want to do housemanship in Lagos, Abuja and Port Harcourt. They don’t want to go to Borno or Adamawa.”
>>> It was gathered that these young doctors may lose their provisional licences if they are unable to secure spaces for internship.
>>> Shortage of consultants
>>> The MDCN accredits medical colleges to train doctors in the country, and grants provisional licences to medical graduates to practise.
>>> The provisional licence expires in two years if the young doctors are unable to go for the mandatory housemanship.
>>> The MDCN accredits medical schools to train doctors in Nigeria, and it indexes every student in that school from year one till the end.
>>> The provisional licence enables the young doctors to do their housemanship. If a doctor spends two years without doing housemanship, then his provisional licence expires.
>>> Findings show that Nigeria’s doctor-patient ratio is far behind the global best practice. The current ratio in Nigeria is one doctor to 3,000 patients, which is against the World Health Organisation (WHO’s) one doctor to 200 patients.
>>> For the housemanship, the ratio is one consultant to four house officers. This means that only four young doctors would serve under the tutelage of a consultant throughout the duration of their internship.
>>> Checks at the MDCN website show that there are 27 medical and dental colleges fully accredited to produce doctors and dentists across the country.
>>> The council allocates to them the number of doctors and dentists to train based on their existing infrastructure, manpower and fund.
>>> Twenty-seven colleges are to produce a total of 2,725 doctors and dentists annually: 2,550 medical and 175 dental.
>>> Another 500 to 600 doctors graduate annually from foreign medical colleges, an official of the MDCN said.
>>> There are 79 fully accredited medical facilities across the country with 2,921 approved slots for housemanship annually.
>>> The information on the council’s website shows that out of the 79 facilities, 22 are teaching hospitals with 1,773 annual slots for housemanship: 1,636 for medical and 137 for dental.
>>> There are 21 accredited federal medical centres with an annual capacity to absorb 412 medical and 14 dental personnel, totalling 426.
>>> There are also 36 accredited general, specialist and military hospitals in the country, with a mandate to train 710 medical and 52 dental students for housemanship yearly.
>>> Hundreds of doctors chasing fewer slots
>>> The National Hospital, Abuja, with an approved quota of only 48 doctors, has so far received over 500 applications. The hospital conducted housemanship exams for the doctors last week.
>>> A source at the hospital said the senior officials were under undue pressure from parents and government officials seeking slots for their wards.
>>> The spokesperson of the hospital, Dr Tayo Haastrup, said many doctors had applied for this year’s housemanship, but only few would be considered.
>>> The University of Abuja Teaching Hospital, Gwagwalada, received an average of 500 applications though it can only admit 32 doctors.
>>> “We have exams once a year in March/April, and there are no less than 300 applicants. Sometime back we got 500. It is really a matter of concern,” the chief medical director of the hospital, Dr Peter Alabi, said.
>>> The three general hospitals in the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) at Wuse, Maitama, Garki and Asokoro, have a total absorption capacity of 84 slots, but they receive an average of 60 applications per week.
>>> “The total slots approved by the MDCN are 84; that is, 24 each for Maitama, Asokoro and Wuse, and 12 for Garki. It takes about two rounds of employment to fill the slots, so there are no new slots. We are only replacing vacancies. The slots are already full from previous rounds of employment.
>>> “There are about 30 open slots in the FCT district hospitals; and right now, we are getting on average 60 applications every week. It is outrageous, it is crazy. It isn’t just a problem in the FCT hospitals, it’s a national problem,” the general manager of the FCT Hospitals Management Board, Muhammed Aminu Mai said.
>>> The University of Port Harcourt Teaching Hospital is grappling with over 1,000 applications for just 84 slots. The chairman of the Joint Health Union in the hospital, Mr. Christian Awaji said, “The teaching hospital has only 84 slots every year for the programme while about 1,000 candidates apply. Presently, the management is processing 1,000 applications while only 84 slots are available.”
>>> The Federal Teaching Hospital (formerly Federal Medical Centre), Gombe, has only 32 approved spaces for all the medical personnel doing their one-year compulsory post-graduation housemanship annually, but over 100 applied, the chief medical director of the centre, Dr Abubakar Sa’idu said.
>>> The Usman Danfodiyo Teaching Hospital, Sokoto, has employed 68 house officers out of the 75 that applied and 98 interns out of 120 applicants, the chief medical director of the institution, Dr Yakubu Ahmed said.
>>> The Jos University Teaching Hospital (JUTH) received an average of 300 applications for its 60 slots.
>>> The Barau Dikko Teaching Hospital, Kaduna has only 12 slots for the housemanship, but hundreds of people applied.
>>> “When we exceed that number we take them to the 44 Reference Hospital, but the state government pays them. We are at the point of inviting the MDCN to review the number of house officers that can be trained in the hospital,” a doctor in the institution told Daily Trust on Sunday.
>>> Prof Wale Oke said the LASUTH had the approval to take 60 doctors for housemanship, but over 200 applied annually.
>>> Also, the annual quota for the AKTH is 60, but about 150 doctors applied, the director of public relations in the hospital, Alhaji Aminu Inuwa, said.
>>> The chief medical director of the Ahmadu Bello University Teaching Hospital (ABUTH), Professor Lawal Khalid, however, said the situation had improved there.
>>> “It is not as bad as it used to be. A possible reason for such long queues in some hospitals could be because some of the young doctors prefer to do their housemanship in particular hospitals,” he said.
>>> The University of Maiduguri Teaching Hospital has 60 slots for the internship.
>>> But the information officer of the Federal Medical Centre, Yola, Muhammad Adamu Dodo, said the institution accepted all internship applicants.
>>> Dodo added that there are fewer graduates of Medicine and Pharmacy in Adamawa and its neighbouring states.
>>> “There is no difficulty in accepting applicants. We are lucky the competition is not very high in the states around us,” he said.
>>> Something must be done
>>> Dr Hauwa Muhammad, who is currently undergoing training at the Surgical Department of the AKTH said, “There is too much stress; the work is too much for us because we are few in the hospital.”
>>> Dr AbdulRahaman Moronkola, an official of the Association of Resident Doctors, Lagos University Teaching Hospital (LUTH), Idi-Araba, said the problem was caused by the government and training institutions.
>>> “We are producing more doctors while government is not producing more training avenues,” he said, adding that the management of tertiary health centres intentionally shortchange the government by refusing to fill up the quota allocated to them.
>>> He called on the government to monitor teaching hospitals to guard against any form of malpractice.
>>> The registrar of the MDCN, Dr Abdulmumin Ibrahim, said poor funding, preference by doctors to serve in urban areas, poor infrastructure, and over-aged doctors, were the reasons why hospitals take less than the slots allocated to them.
>>> He said if the above factors were taken care of, medical centres have enough slots for the number of doctors produced annually.
>>>
>>> Read more at Doctors everywhere but no hospitals for them
>>>
>>> --
>>> You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "ANPA (Carolinas)" group.
>>> To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to anpa-carolinas+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com.
>>> To post to this group, send email to anpa-carolinas@googlegroups.com.
>>> Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/anpa-carolinas.
>>> For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
>> To unsubscribe from this list please goto http://archives.simplelists.com
> To unsubscribe from this list please goto http://www.simplelists.com/confirm.php?u=KWp9at7yYOKzJr3cfLealoI8ekU22Ysa