What is clearly not canon.... Terrence Fugate (26 Apr 2026 15:03 UTC)
Re: [HBP] What is clearly not canon.... David Johnson (26 Apr 2026 15:58 UTC)
Re: [HBP] What is clearly not canon.... Terrence Fugate (26 Apr 2026 17:04 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Beam distrusted centralized governments? Jay P Hailey (27 Apr 2026 01:49 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Beam distrusted centralized governments? Jay P Hailey (27 Apr 2026 02:55 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Beam distrusted centralized governments? David Johnson (27 Apr 2026 23:16 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Beam distrusted centralized governments? Jay P Hailey (28 Apr 2026 05:04 UTC)
Re: [HBP] What is clearly not canon.... David Sooby (27 Apr 2026 01:07 UTC)

Re: [HBP] Beam distrusted centralized governments? Jay P Hailey 28 Apr 2026 05:04 UTC

> This is a reasonable conclusion except we know that while Beam was
> generally pessimistic about the prospects for positive, long-term change
> he wrote yarn after yarn which ended with the impression that changes
> for the good had been accomplished.

Oh, agreed.  But it was long, hard, and definitely didn't go in straight
lines.

HBP seems to really want us to understand that human nature doesn't
change over thousands of years, spaceship or no.

But the 20th century was definitely more fun to live in than the 10th,
so progress is a thing -

usually not clearly understood by the people who live through it.