Vikings vs Imperials David Johnson (14 Mar 2026 05:34 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials Terrence Fugate (14 Mar 2026 15:08 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials David Johnson (14 Mar 2026 22:07 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials Jon Crocker (15 Mar 2026 05:16 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials David Johnson (15 Mar 2026 06:21 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials Terrence Fugate (15 Mar 2026 16:01 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials David Johnson (15 Mar 2026 18:09 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials Terrence Fugate (15 Mar 2026 18:17 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials David Johnson (15 Mar 2026 19:04 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials Terrence Fugate (15 Mar 2026 20:08 UTC)
Way of the Sword Worlds (was: Vikings vs Imperials) David Johnson (15 Mar 2026 20:19 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Way of the Sword Worlds (was: Vikings vs Imperials) Mike Robertson (15 Mar 2026 21:17 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Way of the Sword Worlds Jay P Hailey (15 Mar 2026 21:59 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Way of the Sword Worlds Jay P Hailey (15 Mar 2026 21:59 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Way of the Sword Worlds Jay P Hailey (15 Mar 2026 21:17 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Way of the Sword Worlds (was: Vikings vs Imperials) Terrence Fugate (15 Mar 2026 21:17 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Something fundamentally unworkable? Jay P Hailey (16 Mar 2026 01:55 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Something fundamentally unworkable? Terrence Fugate (16 Mar 2026 22:24 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Something fundamentally unworkable? David Johnson (17 Mar 2026 00:22 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Something fundamentally unworkable? Terrence Fugate (17 Mar 2026 01:00 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Something fundamentally unworkable? David Sooby (19 Mar 2026 01:41 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Something fundamentally unworkable? Jon Crocker (19 Mar 2026 02:25 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Something fundamentally unworkable? Terrence Fugate (19 Mar 2026 02:39 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Something fundamentally unworkable? Terrence Fugate (19 Mar 2026 02:32 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Something fundamentally unworkable? David Johnson (19 Mar 2026 03:02 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Something fundamentally unworkable? Gordon Johansen (19 Mar 2026 14:38 UTC)
Empire economics (was: Vikings vs Imperials) David Johnson (15 Mar 2026 21:24 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials David Sooby (16 Mar 2026 01:56 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials dbernat (15 Mar 2026 20:12 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials David Johnson (15 Mar 2026 21:30 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials Terrence Fugate (15 Mar 2026 05:18 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials Jay P Hailey (15 Mar 2026 22:23 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials dbernat (15 Mar 2026 16:01 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials David Johnson (15 Mar 2026 17:59 UTC)
Re: [HBP] Vikings vs Imperials Terrence Fugate (15 Mar 2026 18:17 UTC)

Re: [HBP] Something fundamentally unworkable? Jay P Hailey 16 Mar 2026 00:51 UTC

On 3/15/26 15:46, David Johnson wrote:
> Hi Terry.
>
>> Piper wrote one thing that struck me as "Spooky.":
>> -----
>> "It may just be,” he added, “that there is something fundamentally
>> unworkable about government itself. As long as Homo sapiens terra is a
>> wild animal, which he has always been and always will be until he
>> evolves into something different in a million or so years, maybe a
>> workable system of government is a political-science impossibility,
>> just as transmutation of elements was a physical-science impossibility
>> as long as they tried to do it by chemical means.”
>> ------
>> Something to think about at least.
>
> Sure, but let's not forget Bentrick's rejoinder to Trask: "Then we'll
> just have to make it work the best way we can, and when it breaks down,
> hope the next try will work a little better, for a little longer."

Can't say I find much to disagree with there.

Maybe perfect isn't on the menu.  But "better" probably is.